We need the military to keep us safe, most of us get that. We also understand that the Navy has vitally important activities that – however unfortunately – can lead to injury and death of marine mammals. The government goes to some length to insure that those Navy activities have a minimum impact by requiring them to submit fairly complex documents every five years, based in part on what impact they had in the previous five-year period.
At issue here is that although the Navy and NOAA Fisheries have already established allowable “takes” (marine mammals that can be killed or displaced) for 2019 through 2023, they now want to extend the period an additional two years without having to reassess the effect they are having on marine mammal populations.
In other words, the Navy won’t have to take into account how much changing ocean conditions will alter the statistics – we have already seen that population distributions are changing for many whale and dolphin species as they follow their prey. For instance, gray whales appear to be starving in some cases, humpback entanglements have risen as they come in closer to shore and encounter crab pots, and diseases such as the morbillivirus decimate cetaceans in parts of their range. Young California sea lions are stranding in unprecedented numbers.
Complicating everything is that Blob 2.0 is forming off the West Coast which is expected to further alter marine mammal health and distribution (graphic and original NOAA data are below).
Comments to NOAA can be made here by October 15th:
Taking and Importing Marine Mammals; Taking Marine Mammals Incidental to the U.S. Navy Training and Testing Activities in the Hawaii-Southern California Training and Testing Study Area
Please take a few minutes to submit your comment to NOAA, the process is simple but be aware that NOAA will only consider well-grounded comments in their decision making. There’s no harm in venting your feelings though, and NOAA needs to know how the public feels so any comment you care to make will be read.
Data from NOAA documents
“NMFS has reviewed the Navy’s data and analysis and determined that it is complete and accurate, and NMFS agrees that the following stressors have the potential to result in takes of marine mammals from the Navy’s planned activities:
Acoustics (sonar and other transducers; air guns; pile driving/extraction);
Explosives (explosive shock wave and sound, assumed to encompass the risk due to fragmentation); and
Physical Disturbance and Strike (vessel strike).”

(Level A takes are possibly lethal, Level B takes disturb or disrupt):
3,162 potentially lethal 10,775,414 disturbed/displaced during TESTING
1,598 potentially lethal 7,187,158 disturbed/displaced during TRAINING
The following is a list of species that can possibly be killed in BOTH Navy training and Navy testing activities; alarming because some species (such as dwarf sperm whales) are impacted out of scale to what is known about them:
Comments to NOAA can be made here by October 15th:
Taking and Importing Marine Mammals; Taking Marine Mammals Incidental to the U.S. Navy Training and Testing Activities in the Hawaii-Southern California Training and Testing Study Area
The following shows the both Level A and Level B “takes” for each species in Navy testing, followed by the list of “takes” in Navy training activities:
Expected takes during Testing Exercises:
Level A Level B Species Stock
0 205 Blue whale * Central North Pacific
6 7,116 Blue whale * Eastern North Pacific
0 167 Bryde’s whale † Eastern Tropical Pacific
0 631 Bryde’s whale † Hawaiian †
0 7,731 Fin whale * California, Oregon, & Washington
0 197 Fin whale * Hawaiian
7 7,962 Humpback whale † California, Oregon, & Washington †
12 34,437 Humpback whale † Central North Pacific
7 4,119 Minke whale California, Oregon, & Washington
6 20,237 Minke whale Hawaiian
0 333 Sei whale * Eastern North Pacific
0 677 Sei whale * Hawaiian
27 16,703 Gray whale † Eastern North Pacific
0 19 Gray whale † Western North Pacific †
0 8,834 Sperm whale * California, Oregon, & Washington
0 10,341 Sperm whale * Hawaiian
215 84,232 Dwarf sperm whale Hawaiian
94 33,431 Pygmy sperm whale Hawaiian
149 38,609 Kogia whales California, Oregon, & Washington
0 8,524 Baird’s beaked whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 23,491 Blainville’s beaked whale Hawaiian
0 47,178 Cuvier’s beaked whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 7,898 Cuvier’s beaked whale Hawaiian
0 82,293 Longman’s beaked whale Hawaiian
0 25,404 Mesoplodon spp (beaked whale guild) California, Oregon, & Washington
0 1,295 Bottlenose dolphin California Coastal
13 201,619 Bottlenose dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington Offshore
0 13,080 Bottlenose dolphin Hawaiian Pelagic
0 500 Bottlenose dolphin Kauai & Niihau
10 57,288 Bottlenose dolphin Oahu
0 1,052 Bottlenose dolphin 4-Island
0 291 Bottlenose dolphin Hawaii
0 4,353 False killer whale † Hawaii Pelagic
0 2,710 False killer whale † Main Hawaiian Islands Insular †
0 1,585 False killer whale † Northwestern Hawaiian Islands
4 177,198 Fraser’s dolphin Hawaiian
0 460 Killer whale Eastern North Pacific Offshore
0 855 Killer whale Eastern North Pacific Transient/West Coast Transient
0 513 Killer whale Hawaiian
99 784,965 Long-beaked common dolphin California
0 14,137 Melon-headed whale Hawaiian Islands
0 1,278 Melon-headed whale Kohala Resident
57 357,001 Northern right whale dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
19 274,892 Pacific white-sided dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 17,739 Pantropical spotted dolphin Hawaii Island
0 42,318 Pantropical spotted dolphin Hawaii Pelagic
0 28,860 Pantropical spotted dolphin Oahu
0 1,816 Pantropical spotted dolphin 4-Island
0 35,531 Pygmy killer whale Hawaiian
0 2,977 Pygmy killer whale Tropical
45 477,389 Risso’s dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 40,800 Risso’s dolphin Hawaiian
0 26,769 Rough-toothed dolphin Hawaiian
0 0 Rough-toothed dolphin NSD
307 5,875,431 Short-beaked common dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
6 6,341 Short-finned pilot whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 53,627 Short-finned pilot whale Hawaiian
0 609 Spinner dolphin Hawaii Island
0 18,870 Spinner dolphin Hawaii Pelagic
0 1,961 Spinner dolphin Kauai & Niihau
8 10,424 Spinner dolphin Oahu & 4-Island
5 777,001 Striped dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 32,806 Striped dolphin Hawaiian
894 171,250 Dall’s porpoise California, Oregon, & Washington
629 460,145 California sea lion U.S
0 3,342 Guadalupe fur seal * Mexico
0 62,138 Northern fur seal California
48 19,214 Harbor seal California
5 938 Hawaiian monk seal * Hawaiian
490 241,277 Northern elephant seal California
Totals: 3,162 potentially lethal 10,775,414 disturbed/displaced during Testing Exercises
* ESA-listed species (all stocks) within the HSTT Study Area.
† Only designated stocks are ESA-listed.
Expected takes during Training Exercises:
Level A Level B Species Stock
0 93 Blue whale * Central North Pacific
0 5,679 Blue whale * Eastern North Pacific
0 97 Bryde’s whale † Eastern Tropical Pacific
0 278 Bryde’s whale † Hawaiian †
7 6,662 Fin whale * California, Oregon, & Washington
0 108 Fin whale * Hawaiian
0 4,961 Humpback whale † California, Oregon, & Washington †
19 23,750 Humpback whale † Central North Pacific
0 1,855 Minke whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 9,822 Minke whale Hawaiian
0 178 Sei whale * Eastern North Pacific
0 329 Sei whale * Hawaiian
0 13,077 Gray whale † Eastern North Pacific
0 15 Gray whale † Western North Pacific †
0 7,409 Sperm whale * California, Oregon, & Washington
0 5,269 Sperm whale * Hawaiian
197 43,374 Dwarf sperm whale Hawaiian
83 17,396 Pygmy sperm whale Hawaiian
94 20,766 Kogia whales California, Oregon, & Washington
0 4,841 Baird’s beaked whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 11,455 Blainville’s beaked whale Hawaiian
28 30,180 Cuvier’s beaked whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 3,784 Cuvier’s beaked whale Hawaiian
0 41,965 Longman’s beaked whale Hawaiian
15 16,383 Mesoplodon spp (beaked whale guild) California, Oregon, & Washington
0 11,158 Bottlenose dolphin California Coastal
8 158,700 Bottlenose dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington Offshore
0 8,469 Bottlenose dolphin Hawaiian Pelagic
0 3,091 Bottlenose dolphin Kauai & Niihau
0 3,230 Bottlenose dolphin Oahu
0 1,129 Bottlenose dolphin 4-Island
0 260 Bottlenose dolphin Hawaii
0 2,287 False killer whale † Hawaii Pelagic
0 1,256 False killer whale † Main Hawaiian Islands Insular †
0 837 False killer whale † Northwestern Hawaiian Islands
9 85,193 Fraser’s dolphin Hawaiian
0 236 Killer whale Eastern North Pacific Offshore
0 438 Killer whale Eastern North Pacific Transient/West Coast Transient
0 279 Killer whale Hawaiian
34 805,063 Long-beaked common dolphin California
0 7,678 Melon-headed whale Hawaiian Islands
0 1,119 Melon-headed whale Kohala Resident
22 280,066 Northern right whale dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
14 213,380 Pacific white-sided dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 9,568 Pantropical spotted dolphin Hawaii Island
0 24,805 Pantropical spotted dolphin Hawaii Pelagic
0 1,349 Pantropical spotted dolphin Oahu
0 2,513 Pantropical spotted dolphin 4-Island
0 18,347 Pygmy killer whale Hawaiian
0 1,928 Pygmy killer whale Tropical
24 339,334 Risso’s dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 19,027 Risso’s dolphin Hawaiian
0 14,851 Rough-toothed dolphin Hawaiian
0 0 Rough-toothed dolphin NSD
304 3,795,732 Short-beaked common dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 6,253 Short-finned pilot whale California, Oregon, & Washington
0 29,269 Short-finned pilot whale Hawaiian
0 1,394 Spinner dolphin Hawaii Island
0 9,534 Spinner dolphin Hawaii Pelagic
0 9,277 Spinner dolphin Kauai & Niihau
0 1,987 Spinner dolphin Oahu & 4-Island
20 371,328 Striped dolphin California, Oregon, & Washington
0 16,270 Striped dolphin Hawaiian
478 115,353 Dall’s porpoise California, Oregon, & Washington
36 334,332 California sea lion U.S
0 6,167 Guadalupe fur seal Mexico
7 36,921 Northern fur seal California
12 15,898 Harbor seal California
0 372 Hawaiian monk seal Hawaiian
187 151,754 Northern elephant seal California
Totals:
1,598 potentially lethal 7,187,158 disturbed/displaced during Training Exercises
Changing ocean conditions are impacting everything in the Navy permit area (and beyond)
from plankton to blue whales (the graphic is from NOAA).
The Blob 2.0
You must be logged in to post a comment.